| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe30 | ONU ball on ONU30. |
| | | Joshua Howells kickoff 60 yards to the COE10, Joe Langenberg return 15 yards to the COE25 (Caleb McKinley). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe25 | Brendan Leiran rush for 2 yards to the COE27 (Josh Tornstrom). |
| Coe | 2-8 | at Coe27 | Brendan Leiran rush for 5 yards to the COE32 (Josh Tornstrom;Brandon Ruemler). |
| Coe | 3-3 | at Coe32 | Brendan Leiran rush for 4 yards to the COE36, 1ST DOWN COE (Josh Tornstrom;Junaid Bakr). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe36 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Joe Langenberg for 27 yards to the ONU37, 1ST DOWN COE (Brandon Ruemler). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu37 | Brendan Leiran rush for 4 yards to the ONU33 (E. Esparza). |
| Coe | 2-6 | at Onu33 | Joe Langenberg rush for 3 yards to the ONU30 (Tony Turner). |
| Coe | 3-3 | at Onu30 | PENALTY COE false start 4 yards to the ONU34. |
| Coe | 3-7 | at Onu34 | Brad Boyle pass incomplete to Kris Hopkins (K. Komlassan). |
| Coe | 4-7 | at Onu34 | Brad Boyle pass incomplete to Jared Kuehner. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 41 yards, TOP 02:55 |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu34 | OLIVET NAZARENE UNIV drive start at 12:05. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu34 | David Payne rush for 14 yards to the ONU48, 1ST DOWN ONU (Jacob Lower). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu48 | M. Ho-Lewis rush for 6 yards to the COE46 (Jacob Lower). |
| Onu | 2-4 | at Coe46 | M. Ho-Lewis rush for no gain to the COE46 (M. Montgomery). |
| Onu | 3-4 | at Coe46 | Rico Prestia rush for no gain to the COE46 (Nat. Steinbronn). |
| Onu | 4-4 | at Coe46 | Joshua Howells punt 43 yards to the COE3, downed. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 20 yards, TOP 02:26 |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe03 | COE COLLEGE drive start at 09:39. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe03 | Brad Boyle rush for 10 yards to the COE13, 1ST DOWN COE (Mark Kosrow). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe13 | Brad Boyle rush for 3 yards to the COE16 (Tony Turner). |
| Coe | 2-7 | at Coe16 | Brendan Leiran rush for 8 yards to the COE24, 1ST DOWN COE (Ben Tobey). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe24 | Timeout Coe College, clock 07:56. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe24 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Jared Kuehner for 7 yards to the COE31 (Brandon Ruemler). |
| Coe | 2-3 | at Coe31 | Brendan Leiran rush for 3 yards to the COE34, 1ST DOWN COE (Brandon Ruemler). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe34 | Brendan Leiran rush for 9 yards to the COE43 (Nathan Schott). |
| Coe | 2-1 | at Coe43 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Joe Langenberg for 21 yards to the ONU36, 1ST DOWN COE (Will Cummings). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu36 | Brendan Leiran rush for 6 yards to the ONU30 (Tyreze Taylor;M. Williams). |
| Coe | 2-4 | at Onu30 | Brad Boyle rush for 2 yards to the ONU28 (Will Cummings). |
| Coe | 3-2 | at Onu28 | Brendan Leiran rush for 5 yards to the ONU23, 1ST DOWN COE (Keith Nunez). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu23 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Keaton Juergens for 14 yards to the ONU9, 1ST DOWN COE (Keith Nunez). |
| Coe | 1-G | at Onu09 | Joe Langenberg rush for 3 yards to the ONU6 (Nathan Schott;K. Komlassan). |
| Coe | 2-G | at Onu06 | Brendan Leiran rush for no gain to the ONU6 (Brandon Ruemler). |
| Coe | 3-G | at Onu06 | Brad Boyle sacked for loss of 6 yards to the ONU12 (M. Williams). |
| Coe | 4-G | at Onu12 | Wes Anderson field goal attempt from 29 MISSED - wide right, spot at ONU20, clock 02:15. |
| | | Drive: 15 plays, 85 yards, TOP 07:24 |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu20 | OLIVET NAZARENE UNIV drive start at 02:15. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu20 | M. Ho-Lewis rush for 2 yards to the ONU22 (Tyler Hemry). |
| Onu | 2-8 | at Onu22 | Rico Prestia pass complete to Josh Long for 15 yards to the ONU37, 1ST DOWN ONU (D. Johnson;Austin Lloyd). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu37 | Rico Prestia pass incomplete to David Payne (Jacob Breitbach). |
| Onu | 2-10 | at Onu37 | M. Ho-Lewis rush for 5 yards to the ONU42, out-of-bounds (Ben Carr). |
| Onu | 3-5 | at Onu42 | Timeout Olivet Nazarene Univ, clock 00:37. |
| Onu | 3-5 | at Onu42 | Rico Prestia rush for 13 yards to the COE45, 1ST DOWN ONU (Team). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Coe45 | Rico Prestia rush for 3 yards to the COE42 (Jacob Lower). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 38 yards, TOP 03:31 |
| | | Coe College 0, Olivet Nazarene Univ 0 |
| Onu | 2-7 | at Coe42 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Onu | 2-7 | at Coe42 | Rico Prestia pass complete to Joshua Howells for 4 yards to the COE38, out-of-bounds (Jacob Lower). |
| Onu | 3-3 | at Coe38 | Rico Prestia rush for 8 yards to the COE30 (Jacob Breitbach), PENALTY ONU holding 10 yards to the COE48, NO PLAY. |
| Onu | 3-13 | at Coe48 | Timeout Olivet Nazarene Univ, clock 13:59. |
| Onu | 3-13 | at Coe48 | Rico Prestia pass incomplete to Zach Cooper. |
| Onu | 4-13 | at Coe48 | Joshua Howells punt 33 yards to the COE15, Justin Snorton return 3 yards to the COE18, out-of-bounds (Mike Barkley). |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 32 yards, TOP 03:31 |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe18 | COE COLLEGE drive start at 13:44. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe18 | Joe Langenberg rush for 5 yards to the COE23 (Tony Turner;David Prater), PENALTY COE illegal procedure 5 yards to the COE13, NO PLAY. |
| Coe | 1-15 | at Coe13 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Brendan Leiran for 8 yards to the COE21 (David Prater). |
| Coe | 2-7 | at Coe21 | Brendan Leiran rush for 8 yards to the COE29, 1ST DOWN COE (Brandon Ruemler). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe29 | Joe Langenberg rush for 1 yard to the COE30 (John Litrenta). |
| Coe | 2-9 | at Coe30 | Brad Boyle pass incomplete to Jared Kuehner, PENALTY COE holding 10 yards to the COE20, NO PLAY. |
| Coe | 2-19 | at Coe20 | Brad Boyle rush for 16 yards to the COE36 (Mark Kosrow;Nicholas Smith). |
| Coe | 3-3 | at Coe36 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Nick Ratchford for 6 yards to the COE42, 1ST DOWN COE (Keith Nunez). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe42 | Brad Boyle rush for loss of 2 yards to the COE40 (Brandon Ruemler;K. Komlassan). |
| Coe | 2-12 | at Coe40 | Brendan Leiran rush for 16 yards to the ONU44, 1ST DOWN COE (Mark Kosrow;Nathan Schott). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu44 | Brad Boyle pass incomplete to Joe Langenberg (Marcus Waller). |
| Coe | 2-10 | at Onu44 | Jacob Frederick rush for 1 yard to the ONU43 (Brandon Ruemler). |
| Coe | 3-9 | at Onu43 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Brendan Leiran for no gain to the ONU43 (Brandon Ruemler). |
| Coe | 4-9 | at Onu43 | Wes Anderson punt 29 yards to the ONU14, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 39 yards, TOP 05:16 |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu14 | OLIVET NAZARENE UNIV drive start at 08:28. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu14 | M. Ho-Lewis rush for 2 yards to the ONU16 (Co. Worthington). |
| Onu | 2-8 | at Onu16 | M. Ho-Lewis rush for loss of 1 yard to the ONU15 (Dylan Youel). |
| Onu | 3-9 | at Onu15 | Rico Prestia pass incomplete to Joshua Howells. |
| Onu | 4-9 | at Onu15 | Joshua Howells punt 41 yards to the COE44, Keaton Juergens return 5 yards to the COE49 (John Litrenta). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:33 |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe49 | COE COLLEGE drive start at 06:55. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe49 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Keaton Juergens for 16 yards to the ONU35, 1ST DOWN COE (Keith Nunez;John Litrenta). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu35 | Brad Boyle pass incomplete to Jared Kuehner. |
| Coe | 2-10 | at Onu35 | Brendan Leiran rush for no gain to the ONU35 (David Prater). |
| Coe | 3-10 | at Onu35 | Brendan Leiran rush for 2 yards to the ONU33 (Will Cummings). |
| Coe | 4-8 | at Onu33 | Brad Boyle pass incomplete to Jared Kuehner. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 18 yards, TOP 01:51 |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu33 | OLIVET NAZARENE UNIV drive start at 05:04. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu33 | Issac Austin rush for loss of 6 yards to the ONU27 (Bryce Sampson;Dylan Youel). |
| Onu | 2-16 | at Onu27 | Rico Prestia pass intercepted by D. Johnson at the 50 yardline, D. Johnson return 15 yards to the ONU35 (Issac Austin). |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, minus 6 yards, TOP 01:01 |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu35 | COE COLLEGE drive start at 04:03. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu35 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Joe Langenberg for 5 yards to the ONU30 (Mark Kosrow). |
| Coe | 2-5 | at Onu30 | Brendan Leiran rush for loss of 3 yards to the ONU33 (K. Komlassan). |
| Coe | 3-8 | at Onu33 | PENALTY COE false start 5 yards to the ONU38. |
| Coe | 3-13 | at Onu38 | Brad Boyle pass incomplete to Joe Langenberg (Mark Kosrow). |
| Coe | 4-13 | at Onu38 | Wes Anderson punt 27 yards to the ONU11, fair catch by Andrew Butler. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 3 yards, TOP 01:39 |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu11 | OLIVET NAZARENE UNIV drive start at 02:24. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu11 | Issac Austin rush for 4 yards to the ONU15 (Frank Weymiller). |
| Onu | 2-6 | at Onu15 | Rico Prestia pass incomplete to Andy Bates. |
| Onu | 3-6 | at Onu15 | M. Ho-Lewis rush for loss of 2 yards to the ONU13 (Frank Weymiller). |
| Onu | 4-8 | at Onu13 | Timeout Coe College, clock 01:38. |
| Onu | 4-8 | at Onu13 | Joshua Howells punt 50 yards to the COE37, Keaton Juergens return 6 yards to the COE43 (Damion Fields;Colton Parker). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 2 yards, TOP 00:58 |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe43 | COE COLLEGE drive start at 01:26. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe43 | Brad Boyle rush for 9 yards to the ONU48 (Team). |
| Coe | 2-1 | at Onu48 | Brad Boyle pass intercepted by Nathan Schott at the COE49, Nathan Schott return 0 yards to the COE49 (Team). |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 9 yards, TOP 01:26 |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Coe49 | OLIVET NAZARENE UNIV drive start at 01:04. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Coe49 | Rico Prestia rush for 6 yards to the COE43 (Co. Worthington;Frank Weymiller). |
| Onu | 2-4 | at Coe43 | Rico Prestia pass complete to M. Ho-Lewis for 13 yards to the COE30, 1ST DOWN ONU (Co. Worthington). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Coe30 | Rico Prestia pass complete to Aaron Link for 5 yards to the COE25 (Jacob Breitbach). |
| Onu | 2-5 | at Coe25 | Timeout Olivet Nazarene Univ, clock 00:14. |
| Onu | 2-5 | at Coe25 | A Muzljakovich field goal attempt from 42 GOOD, clock 00:08. |
| | | Olivet Nazarene Univ 3, Coe College 0 |
| Onu | 1-G | at Onu30 | OLIVET NAZARENE UNIV drive start at 00:00. |
| Onu | 1-G | at Onu30 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 24 yards, TOP 00:05 |
| | | Olivet Nazarene Univ 3, Coe College 0 |
| Onu | 1-G | at Onu30 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Onu | 1-G | at Onu30 | COE ball on COE30. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 24 yards, TOP 00:05 |
| | | Keaton Juergens kickoff 50 yards to the ONU20, David Payne return 7 yards to the ONU27 (Jacob Lower). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu27 | OLIVET NAZARENE UNIV drive start at 14:55. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu27 | Rico Prestia rush for 26 yards to the COE47, 1ST DOWN ONU (Bryce Sampson). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Coe47 | M. Ho-Lewis rush for no gain to the COE47 (Jacob Breitbach). |
| Onu | 2-10 | at Coe47 | Rico Prestia rush for loss of 4 yards to the ONU49 (Ben Carr). |
| Onu | 3-14 | at Onu49 | Rico Prestia pass incomplete to Kyle Walker. |
| Onu | 4-14 | at Onu49 | Joshua Howells punt 51 yards to the COE0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 22 yards, TOP 02:08 |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe20 | COE COLLEGE drive start at 12:47. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe20 | Brad Boyle rush for 7 yards to the COE27, out-of-bounds. |
| Coe | 2-3 | at Coe27 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Kris Hopkins for 9 yards to the COE36, 1ST DOWN COE, out-of-bounds. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe36 | Brendan Leiran rush for 5 yards to the COE41 (David Lyon). |
| Coe | 2-5 | at Coe41 | Brad Boyle pass incomplete to Jared Kuehner, PENALTY ONU pass interference 15 yards to the ONU44, 1ST DOWN COE, NO PLAY. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu44 | Brendan Leiran rush for 8 yards to the ONU36 (Josh Tornstrom). |
| Coe | 2-2 | at Onu36 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Jared Kuehner for 6 yards to the ONU30, 1ST DOWN COE (Brandon Ruemler). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu30 | Brad Boyle pass incomplete to Jared Kuehner. |
| Coe | 2-10 | at Onu30 | PENALTY COE false start 6 yards to the ONU36. |
| Coe | 2-16 | at Onu36 | Brad Boyle pass incomplete to Nick Ratchford (David Prater). |
| Coe | 3-16 | at Onu36 | Brad Boyle pass intercepted by Keith Nunez at the ONU20, Keith Nunez return 17 yards to the ONU37 (Carring. Daniel). |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 44 yards, TOP 02:15 |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu37 | OLIVET NAZARENE UNIV drive start at 10:32. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu37 | Rico Prestia rush for 5 yards to the ONU42 (Tyler Hemry). |
| Onu | 2-5 | at Onu42 | Rico Prestia rush for 17 yards to the COE41, 1ST DOWN ONU (Austin Lloyd). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Coe41 | Rico Prestia pass complete to Joshua Howells for 18 yards to the COE23, 1ST DOWN ONU. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Coe23 | Rico Prestia pass incomplete to Kyle Walker. |
| Onu | 2-10 | at Coe23 | Rico Prestia pass complete to Joshua Howells for 23 yards to the COE0, 1ST DOWN ONU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 08:37. |
| | | A Muzljakovich kick attempt good. |
| | | Olivet Nazarene Univ 10, Coe College 0 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 63 yards, TOP 02:11 |
| | | A Muzljakovich kickoff 63 yards to the COE7, Bryce Sampson return 34 yards to the COE41 (A Muzljakovich), PENALTY COE holding 20 yards to the COE21, 1st and 10, COE ball on COE21. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe21 | COE COLLEGE drive start at 08:21. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe21 | Brendan Leiran rush for 2 yards to the COE23 (Nathan Schott). |
| Coe | 2-8 | at Coe23 | Joe Langenberg rush for 6 yards to the COE29 (Nathan Schott). |
| Coe | 3-2 | at Coe29 | Brendan Leiran rush for 3 yards to the COE32, 1ST DOWN COE (Nathan Schott). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe32 | Brad Boyle pass intercepted by Keith Nunez at the ONU30, Keith Nunez return 11 yards to the ONU41 (Joe Langenberg). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 11 yards, TOP 01:22 |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu41 | OLIVET NAZARENE UNIV drive start at 06:59. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu41 | Rico Prestia pass complete to Joshua Howells for 3 yards to the ONU44 (Bryce Sampson). |
| Onu | 2-7 | at Onu44 | Rico Prestia rush for loss of 4 yards to the ONU40 (Frank Weymiller). |
| Onu | 3-11 | at Onu40 | Rico Prestia pass complete to Joshua Howells for 49 yards to the COE11, 1ST DOWN ONU (Bryce Sampson). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Coe11 | Rico Prestia rush for loss of 5 yards to the COE16 (Tyler Hemry). |
| Onu | 2-15 | at Coe16 | Kyle Walker rush for 6 yards to the COE10 (Bryce Sampson). |
| Onu | 3-9 | at Coe10 | Rico Prestia pass incomplete to Joshua Howells. |
| Onu | 4-9 | at Coe10 | A Muzljakovich field goal attempt from 27 MISSED - wide left, spot at COE20, clock 03:27. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 49 yards, TOP 03:32 |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe20 | COE COLLEGE drive start at 03:27. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe20 | Brendan Leiran rush for 5 yards to the COE25 (Josh Tornstrom). |
| Coe | 2-5 | at Coe25 | Brad Boyle pass incomplete to Kris Hopkins. |
| Coe | 3-5 | at Coe25 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Nick Ratchford for 8 yards to the COE33, 1ST DOWN COE (Keith Nunez). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe33 | Brad Boyle rush for 8 yards to the COE41 (Team). |
| Coe | 2-2 | at Coe41 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Joe Langenberg for 13 yards to the ONU46, 1ST DOWN COE (Will Cummings). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu46 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Jacob Frederick for 5 yards to the ONU41 (Will Cummings), PENALTY ONU holding 10 yards to the ONU31, 1ST DOWN COE. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu31 | 1st and 10. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu31 | Jacob Frederick rush for 6 yards to the ONU25 (Team). |
| Coe | 2-4 | at Onu25 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Joe Langenberg for 1 yard to the ONU24 (John Litrenta). |
| Coe | 3-3 | at Onu24 | Jacob Frederick rush for 7 yards to the ONU17, 1ST DOWN COE (Brandon Ruemler;Nathan Schott). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu17 | Brad Boyle rush for 7 yards to the ONU10 (Tyreze Taylor). |
| Coe | 2-3 | at Onu10 | Brad Boyle rush for 7 yards to the ONU3, 1ST DOWN COE (Team). |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 77 yards, TOP 05:26 |
| | | Olivet Nazarene Univ 10, Coe College 0 |
| Coe | 1-G | at Onu03 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Coe | 1-G | at Onu03 | Brad Boyle rush for 1 yard to the ONU2 (Tony Turner). |
| Coe | 2-G | at Onu02 | Jacob Frederick rush for no gain to the ONU2 (Brandon Ruemler;K. Komlassan). |
| Coe | 3-G | at Onu02 | Jacob Frederick rush for no gain to the ONU2 (Nathan Schott). |
| Coe | 4-G | at Onu02 | Wes Anderson field goal attempt from 19 GOOD, clock 13:06. |
| | | Olivet Nazarene Univ 10, Coe College 3 |
| | | Drive: 15 plays, 78 yards, TOP 05:26 |
| | | Keaton Juergens kickoff 55 yards to the ONU15, David Payne return 8 yards to the ONU23 (Ryan Bach). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu23 | OLIVET NAZARENE UNIV drive start at 13:01. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu23 | Issac Austin rush for 2 yards to the ONU25 (Team). |
| Onu | 2-8 | at Onu25 | Rico Prestia pass incomplete to Andrew Butler. |
| Onu | 3-8 | at Onu25 | Rico Prestia pass incomplete to Andrew Butler. |
| Onu | 4-8 | at Onu25 | Joshua Howells punt 40 yards to the COE35, fair catch by DJ Erkenbrack. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 2 yards, TOP 00:56 |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe35 | COE COLLEGE drive start at 12:05. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe35 | Brad Boyle rush for 13 yards to the COE48, 1ST DOWN COE (M. Williams), PENALTY ONU personal foul 14 yards to the ONU38, 1ST DOWN COE. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu38 | 1st and 10. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu38 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Joe Langenberg for 2 yards to the ONU36 (Mark Kosrow). |
| Coe | 2-8 | at Onu36 | Brad Boyle rush for 2 yards to the ONU34 (Brandon Ruemler). |
| Coe | 3-6 | at Onu34 | Brad Boyle pass incomplete to Nick Ratchford. |
| Coe | 4-6 | at Onu34 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Jared Kuehner for 14 yards to the ONU20, 1ST DOWN COE (Will Cummings). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu20 | Jacob Frederick rush for 4 yards to the ONU16 (Nathan Schott). |
| Coe | 2-6 | at Onu16 | Brad Boyle rush for 16 yards to the ONU0, 1ST DOWN COE, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:38. |
| | | Wes Anderson kick attempt good. |
| | | Coe College 10, Olivet Nazarene Univ 10 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 65 yards, TOP 02:32 |
| | | Keaton Juergens kickoff 49 yards to the ONU21, David Payne return 8 yards to the ONU29 (Kris Schult). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu29 | OLIVET NAZARENE UNIV drive start at 09:33. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu29 | M. Ho-Lewis rush for 7 yards to the ONU36 (Ben Carr). |
| Onu | 2-3 | at Onu36 | Rico Prestia pass complete to Kyle Walker for 27 yards to the COE37, 1ST DOWN ONU (Jacob Breitbach;Austin Lloyd). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Coe37 | M. Ho-Lewis rush for 9 yards to the COE28 (Dylan Youel). |
| Onu | 2-1 | at Coe28 | M. Ho-Lewis rush for loss of 2 yards to the COE30 (Ben Carr). |
| Onu | 3-3 | at Coe30 | Rico Prestia pass incomplete to Kyle Walker (D. Johnson). |
| Onu | 4-3 | at Coe30 | A Muzljakovich field goal attempt from 47 MISSED - wide left, spot at COE30, clock 06:54. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 41 yards, TOP 02:39 |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe30 | COE COLLEGE drive start at 06:54. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe30 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Jacob Frederick for 3 yards to the COE33 (K. Komlassan). |
| Coe | 2-7 | at Coe33 | Jacob Frederick rush for 6 yards to the COE39 (David Prater), fumble by Jacob Frederick recovered by ONU K. Komlassan at COE39. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 9 yards, TOP 00:55 |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Coe39 | OLIVET NAZARENE UNIV drive start at 05:59. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Coe39 | PENALTY ONU false start 5 yards to the COE44. |
| Onu | 1-15 | at Coe44 | Rico Prestia pass complete to Andrew Butler for 4 yards to the COE40 (Nat. Steinbronn). |
| Onu | 2-11 | at Coe40 | Rico Prestia pass complete to Joshua Howells for 3 yards to the COE37 (D. Johnson). |
| Onu | 3-8 | at Coe37 | Timeout Olivet Nazarene Univ, clock 04:42. |
| Onu | 3-8 | at Coe37 | Rico Prestia pass incomplete to Joshua Howells (Co. Worthington). |
| Onu | 4-8 | at Coe37 | Rico Prestia pass complete to Andrew Butler for 4 yards to the COE33 (D. Johnson). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:29 |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe33 | COE COLLEGE drive start at 04:30. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe33 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Joe Langenberg for 6 yards to the COE39 (Mark Kosrow). |
| Coe | 2-4 | at Coe39 | Brad Boyle rush for 3 yards to the COE42 (Team;Team). |
| Coe | 3-1 | at Coe42 | Jacob Frederick rush for 8 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN COE (E. Esparza). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe50 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Jared Kuehner for 16 yards to the ONU34, 1ST DOWN COE (Will Cummings). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu34 | Joe Langenberg rush for 1 yard to the ONU33 (Brandon Ruemler). |
| Coe | 2-9 | at Onu33 | Brad Boyle pass incomplete to Jared Kuehner. |
| Coe | 3-9 | at Onu33 | Brad Boyle pass incomplete to Nick Ratchford. |
| Coe | 4-9 | at Onu33 | Brad Boyle pass incomplete to Nick Ratchford. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 34 yards, TOP 02:43 |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu33 | OLIVET NAZARENE UNIV drive start at 01:47. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu33 | Rico Prestia pass incomplete to Andrew Butler. |
| Onu | 2-10 | at Onu33 | Rico Prestia pass complete to Joshua Howells for 20 yards to the COE47, 1ST DOWN ONU (Austin Lloyd). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Coe47 | Rico Prestia pass intercepted by Bryce Sampson at the COE22, Bryce Sampson return 19 yards to the COE41 (Joshua Howells). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 20 yards, TOP 00:28 |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe41 | COE COLLEGE drive start at 01:19. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Coe41 | Brad Boyle pass incomplete to Kris Hopkins. |
| Coe | 2-10 | at Coe41 | Brad Boyle pass incomplete to Nick Ratchford (Will Cummings). |
| Coe | 3-10 | at Coe41 | Brad Boyle rush for 6 yards to the COE47 (Nathan Schott). |
| Coe | 4-4 | at Coe47 | Timeout Coe College, clock 00:54. |
| Coe | 4-4 | at Coe47 | Wes Anderson punt 32 yards to the ONU21, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 00:32 |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu21 | OLIVET NAZARENE UNIV drive start at 00:47. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu21 | Timeout Olivet Nazarene Univ, clock 00:47. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu21 | Rico Prestia pass incomplete to Joshua Howells. |
| Onu | 2-10 | at Onu21 | M. Ho-Lewis rush for 10 yards to the ONU31, 1ST DOWN ONU (Co. Worthington). |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Onu31 | Rico Prestia rush for 1 yard to the ONU32 (Tyler Hemry). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 11 yards, TOP 00:47 |
| | | Coe College 10, Olivet Nazarene Univ 10 |
| | | Olivet Nazarene Univ 16, Coe College 10 |
| Onu | 2-9 | at Onu32 | End of game, start of OT quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Onu | 2-9 | at Onu32 | ONU ball on COE25. |
| Onu | 2-9 | at Coe25 | ONU ball on COE25. |
| Onu | 2-9 | at Coe25 | 1st and 10. |
| Onu | 1-10 | at Coe25 | M. Ho-Lewis rush for loss of 1 yard to the COE26 (Phillip Hale). |
| Onu | 2-11 | at Coe26 | Rico Prestia sacked for loss of 10 yards to the COE36 (Tyler Hemry). |
| Onu | 3-21 | at Coe36 | Rico Prestia pass incomplete to Joshua Howells. |
| Onu | 4-21 | at Coe36 | Timeout Olivet Nazarene Univ, clock 15:00. |
| Onu | 4-21 | at Coe36 | A Muzljakovich field goal attempt from 53 MISSED - hit right upright, spot at ONU25, clock 15:00. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:47 |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu25 | COE COLLEGE drive start at 15:00. |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu25 | Brad Boyle pass complete to Jared Kuehner for 13 yards to the ONU12, 1ST DOWN COE (Nicholas Smith). |
| Coe | 1-10 | at Onu12 | Joe Langenberg rush for loss of 6 yards to the ONU18 (Nathan Schott). |
| Coe | 2-16 | at Onu18 | Brad Boyle pass intercepted by E. Esparza at the ONU8, E. Esparza return 92 yards to the COE0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 15:00. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 7 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Olivet Nazarene Univ 16, Coe College 10 |
| Onu | 1-G | at Coe03 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Olivet Nazarene Univ 16, Coe College 10 |